01What Google says, and what it does not say
Google's help page on local ranking names three factors: relevance, distance and prominence. It defines prominence as how well-known a business is, based on things like how many websites link to it and how many reviews it has. That page does not mention matching names, addresses or phone numbers across the web. It does say that businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results. So the sourced claim is about accuracy. Whether a mismatch on other sites moves your position, and by how much, is not stated there, and we have not measured it.
- Relevance, distance, prominence: the three factors Google names
- Prominence is based on things like links to your business and reviews
- Complete and accurate info makes a business more likely to appear in local results
- No stated rule or effect size for matching NAP across sites, and we have measured none
02Why the phone number is the field that breaks first
Names and addresses change rarely. Phone numbers get replaced when a mobile is swapped, a landline is dropped, a second line is added for the restaurant or a call-tracking number lands in the website header. They are also written many ways: 0721 000 000, 0721.000.000, +40 721 000 000. A person reads all three as one number, but software that compares text may not. Google's structured data page says to include the country code and area code in the telephone property, so in markup we would write the +40 form and use one written form on the visible pages too.
- Pick one written form and use it everywhere, for example +40 721 000 000
- Structured data: country code and area code in the telephone property (Google)
- Old numbers: forward them or remove them, do not leave them listed
- A call-tracking number is a second number: decide where it may appear
03Which number goes on the Google profile
Google's guidelines for representing your business give phone rules. The number should connect to your individual location, a local number is preferred over a central call-centre line whenever possible, it must be under the direct control of the business, and it must not redirect or refer users to landing pages. Additional numbers can be used on Google Business Profile websites and other local surfaces. A business with several lines, like Santorini Hotel with its reception, restaurant and complaints numbers, therefore has a choice to make: one main number for the profile and the markup, the others labelled where they appear.
- A local number that connects to the individual location, under the business's control
- No premium numbers, no numbers that redirect or refer users to landing pages
- Extra lines are allowed on the website and other local surfaces, labelled by purpose
- One main number in the profile and in the markup
04A one-afternoon audit
List every place your name, address and number appear: Google Business Profile, the site header, footer and contact page, structured data, Facebook and Instagram, the booking platform, directories, invoices and the email signature. Put them in a sheet with the exact text of each. Decide the one written form, then fix in order of visibility: the profile first, then the site, then the platforms customers use to reach you. For a business with one location this is an afternoon, not a project. Repeat it after any move, number change or rebrand. Our local SEO checklist covers the other items a one-location business needs.
- A sheet with every place the name, address and number appear, with the exact text
- One written form, decided once
- Fix the profile first, then the site, then the booking and social platforms
- Re-check after every move, number change or rebrand
05Where PROOF48 is the wrong choice
For one location with a handful of listings, you can do this yourself in an afternoon and PROOF48 is the wrong spend. The FOUND plan, 297 EUR a month, lists Google Business Profile management, local SEO for 5 target keywords, schema, a monthly ranking report and competitor and review monitoring. It does not list a directory clean-up as an item, so we would scope one before promising it. We promise no Google position and no effect from fixing a number. SEO takes months, so FOUND is also the wrong choice if you need customers this week.
- One location, a handful of listings: do it yourself, PROOF48 is the wrong spend
- FOUND: 297 EUR a month, Google Business Profile management, local SEO for 5 keywords, schema, monthly report
- No directory clean-up is listed in FOUND, so it is scoped first
- No promised position, and no promised effect from fixing a number
Three phone lines, published on the site and in structured data
Santorini Hotel, a seafront hotel in Eforie Nord, is the closest we have to this problem. Its case study lists the reception, restaurant and complaints phone lines published on the site and in structured data. That shows the kind of work involved: more than one line, published in two places. We did not measure whether it changed the hotel's position in search or its calls, and the case study publishes no occupancy or booking figures, so it is not evidence of a ranking effect.
See the build: Santorini HotelQuestions, answered
Is NAP consistency a Google ranking factor?
Google's help page on local ranking names relevance, distance and prominence and does not mention matching name, address and phone across sites. It does say complete and accurate info makes a business more likely to appear. We have measured no effect size and state none.
Should my phone number include +40?
Google's structured data guidance for the telephone property says to include the country code and area code. On your visible pages, pick one written form and use it everywhere.
Can I use a call-tracking number?
The Google guidelines page we read does not discuss tracking numbers, so we state no rule. It does say the number must be under the direct control of the business and must not redirect users to landing pages. Ask Google's support before putting a tracking number on your profile.
Does PROOF48 clean up directory listings?
The FOUND plan lists Google Business Profile management, schema and review monitoring. It does not list a directory clean-up as an item, so we would scope it before promising it.
Where PROOF48 fits
NAP consistency means writing your name, address and phone number the same way everywhere they appear. Google's local ranking page says complete and accurate info helps and says nothing about matching across sites, so we cannot size the ranking effect of one wrong number, and we have measured none. A wrong number still loses calls. Fix the profile first, then the site. PROOF48's FOUND plan, at 297 EUR a month, covers the profile and schema.
Cosmin Tiu · Founder, PROOF48
Cosmin has worked in online marketing and software development since 2018, and has built with AI every day since January 2023. He still writes code from scratch daily, in Python, React, Rust and C#. PROOF48 ships business websites in 48 hours and invoices afterwards, so every opinion on this blog was paid for in real builds, not in theory.