01What a marketplace gives you, and what it keeps
A marketplace gives you a crowd that is already shopping and a listing format you do not have to design. In exchange, the platform sets the rules: what it charges, how your listing looks, what you can say to the customer and what you get to keep afterwards. That differs from one marketplace to the next, and we quote no marketplace's fees here, because the page to trust is the marketplace's own. Before you sign up, write down three things from its terms: what it takes per sale, whether you receive the customer's contact details, and what happens to your reviews if you leave. One of our own builds started from that frustration. Rotiseria Baba Novac came to us selling through a delivery aggregator that took a cut of every order and owned the customer relationship, and it wanted its own ordering channel.
- A marketplace gives you traffic that already exists and a listing you do not design
- The platform sets the rules, and you accept them to be listed
- Read its terms for the fee per sale, customer contact details and what happens to your reviews if you leave
- Take fees from the marketplace's own page, never from memory or from a blog
02What your own website gives you
A website is the one address that is yours. Every marketplace listing, Instagram bio and printed leaflet can point to it, and what customers find there is your name, your contact details and your terms. It is also where someone who heard about you from a friend ends up when they search your name. When you pay for a PROOF48 site you own the code, the domain, the hosting account and the content. A business website of up to about five pages is built in 48 hours for 500 to 2,500 EUR, and for a standard 48-hour build nothing is due until you have seen the preview. Our post on whether you need a website if you have Instagram makes the same argument for social media.
- Your name, contact details and terms on an address you control
- One link for every listing, bio and leaflet
- You own the code, domain, hosting account and content after you pay
- Up to about five pages, 48 hours, 500 to 2,500 EUR, paid after the preview
03Which one comes first
It comes down to one question: do you already have customers who know your name? If you do, such as regulars, a market stall or an Instagram following, build the site first. Those people are already coming, a marketplace may charge you for finding them, and your site can take orders by form, email or phone. If you have no customers yet and your product fits a marketplace, list there this week to find out whether anyone wants it, and put up a one-page site of your own in the same week so every listing has somewhere to send people. If you want to sell many products with a cart and checkout on your own domain, that is a store and a bigger decision than this one. Our post on website versus online store covers it.
- Regulars, a stall or a following: site first, orders by form, email or phone
- No customers yet: list on a marketplace and open a one-page site the same week
- Many products with cart and checkout: a store, 2,500 to 4,500 EUR, with its own timeline
- Either way, your name and terms live on your own domain
04Where PROOF48 is the wrong choice
If you only want to list products on an existing marketplace, we are the wrong choice: no PROOF48 plan lists marketplace accounts or listing management. A store with a cart and checkout is 2,500 to 4,500 EUR with its own timeline and is not part of the 48-hour offer; our post on shipping a store in 48 hours explains the difference. Building your own marketplace, with accounts for sellers, publishing and notifications, is web app work. Web apps start at 5,000 EUR with their own timeline, and larger or custom projects may need a deposit as agreed under our terms. If you sell a few things a week to people who already know you, you may need neither a marketplace nor a new site this year.
- Only listing on a marketplace: no PROOF48 plan covers marketplace accounts or listings
- A store with cart and checkout: 2,500 to 4,500 EUR, its own timeline, not the 48-hour offer
- Your own marketplace: web app work, from 5,000 EUR, its own timeline, and a deposit may apply as agreed
- A few sales a week to people who know you: you may need neither
FreshBatch: the marketplace side of the question
FreshBatch is a marketplace where local bakeries, butchers and cafés publish fresh batches as they come out of the oven, and nearby customers get notified. PROOF48 built it end to end: producer accounts, each with its own storefront, live batch publishing from a phone, customer notifications when a batch lands nearby, a LocalProducer category for small independent sellers, and a campaign system for offers. It is live at freshbatch.app with more than 19 businesses publishing on it. That is a platform, not a site for one producer, which is a smaller job. We do not publish FreshBatch's transaction volume.
See the build: FreshBatchQuestions, answered
Can I sell on a marketplace and have my own website?
Yes, and they do different jobs. The marketplace brings people who are already shopping. The website is the address that is yours. Point every listing at it.
Do I keep my customers when I sell on a marketplace?
That depends on the marketplace's own terms. Check whether you receive the customer's contact details before you sign. We run none of them, so we cannot tell you for a particular platform.
What does your site cost, and when do I pay?
500 to 2,500 EUR for a website of up to about five pages, confirmed before we build. For a standard 48-hour build nothing is due until you have seen the preview. Larger or custom projects may require a deposit as agreed.
Can PROOF48 build me a marketplace?
As web app work, yes: from 5,000 EUR, with its own timeline and not in 48 hours. FreshBatch is the live example, and we publish no transaction figures for it.
Where PROOF48 fits
A marketplace gives a small producer reach on the platform's rules. A website gives the producer a name, contact details and terms on an address they own. If you already have customers, build the site first. If you have none, list on a marketplace and open a one-page site the same week. PROOF48 builds that site in 48 hours for 500 to 2,500 EUR, paid after the preview, and says plainly that it does not manage marketplace listings.
Cosmin Tiu · Founder, PROOF48
Cosmin has worked in online marketing and software development since 2018, and has built with AI every day since January 2023. He still writes code from scratch daily, in Python, React, Rust and C#. PROOF48 ships business websites in 48 hours and invoices afterwards, so every opinion on this blog was paid for in real builds, not in theory.