01What the word covers, and what it hides
Anthropic's engineering guide "Building effective agents" (19 December 2024) splits what gets called agentic into workflows, which run on predefined code paths, and agents, where the model directs its own process and tool use. Our post on agents, chatbots and AI employees quotes both definitions. What matters here is that "agentic" is an umbrella, and a product can wear the word while running a fixed script with a model writing the wording. The fixed version is easier to test. Gartner's own press release of 25 June 2025 predicts that over 40% of agentic AI projects will be canceled by the end of 2027, and says only about 130 of the thousands of agentic AI vendors are real. Gartner calls the rebranding of existing products "agent washing".
- Workflow: a model and tools on predefined code paths (Anthropic)
- Agent: the model directs its own process and tool use (Anthropic)
- "Agentic" covers both, so the word alone tells you nothing
- Gartner press release, 25 June 2025: about 130 real vendors among thousands of agentic AI claims
02The test for a five-person business
Anthropic says agents suit open-ended problems where it is difficult or impossible to predict the number of steps, and that you must have some level of trust in the model's decision-making. It recommends extensive testing in sandboxed environments, with guardrails, and finding the simplest solution possible. Put that next to a business of five people and a test follows. Can you write the steps down in advance? Then you need a workflow. Is a wrong action costly, such as a wrong price, a double booking or a message to the wrong client? Then you want fixed steps and a person at the end. Answering the same questions, confirming a slot and chasing a form usually pass the first test. That is our reading, not a measured result.
- Steps can be written down in advance: use a fixed workflow
- A wrong action costs money or trust: fixed steps, a person at the end
- Steps genuinely cannot be predicted: that is where an agent starts to make sense
- Either way, set the limits and test on real cases before it talks to a client
03Five questions for any vendor who says agentic
The buzzword hides a short list of facts, and a vendor who has them will give them to you in writing. Ask which steps are fixed and which are chosen by the model. Ask for the full list of actions it is allowed to take, and what it cannot touch. Ask what happens when a step fails or the model is unsure, and who the named person is that the case goes to. Ask who reads the conversations or logs, and how often. Then ask the question Anthropic's guide supports: could a fixed workflow do this job, and if not, why? A vendor who cannot answer the last one in plain words is probably selling the label. Our earlier post on agents, chatbots and so-called AI employees covers the vocabulary.
- Which steps are fixed, and which does the model choose?
- What is the full list of actions it may take, and what is off limits?
- What happens when a step fails or the model is unsure, and who gets the case?
- Who reads the conversations or logs, and how often?
- Could a fixed workflow do this job? If not, why not?
04What PROOF48 sells instead of the word
Our service pages never use the word agentic. The AI assistant page describes a build in steps: week 1 maps every type of message clients send, week 2 builds the assistant and connects it, with your business rules and a rule for handing a conversation to a person, week 3 tests every case in the map, and you review conversations weekly afterwards. You decide the handoff triggers before launch, such as topic, time of day or client value. AUTOMATE, at 2,997 EUR a month, lists an AI website chatbot that qualifies and books, AI DM and email auto-responders, booking automation with a CRM and two custom automations a month. No cheaper plan contains the chatbot.
- Weeks 1 to 3: map the messages, build and connect, test every case
- Handoff triggers set by you before launch: topic, time of day, client value
- AUTOMATE: 2,997 EUR a month, or 29,970 EUR billed annually
- No plan below AUTOMATE includes the chatbot
05Where PROOF48 is the wrong choice
PROOF48 is the wrong choice if you want software that runs the business unattended: we build defined functions with a handoff to a person. AUTOMATE is the wrong plan if clients mostly reach you on WhatsApp or by phone, because it does not cover them; a standalone WhatsApp or voice assistant is a custom build, priced on request. PROOF48 is also wrong if you need something this week, since the AI assistant page lays out three weeks. And at 2,997 EUR a month AUTOMATE is wrong for a business that gets a handful of messages a week, where a person replying quickly most likely costs less. If you have no website yet, start there: up to about five pages, 500 to 2,500 EUR, built in 48 hours, with no payment before the preview.
- Wrong if you want an autonomous system running the business unattended
- AUTOMATE is wrong if clients mostly use WhatsApp or the phone: not covered, a custom build priced on request
- Wrong if you need it this week: the page lays out three weeks
- Wrong for a handful of messages a week, at 2,997 EUR a month
A long chain with fixed steps, not a free-roaming agent
ATP Spedition's transport system runs from booking through quote, dispatch, delivery, invoice and payment. Its write-up lists a job model for courier, moving and freight, an offline-first driver flow, proof of delivery with photo and signature, VAT calculation, gapless invoicing, and Romanian e-Factura and e-Transport as first-class requirements. Nothing in the write-up says an AI model chooses the steps. A chain with legal consequences, such as invoices, reads to us as a case for defined steps over freedom. That is interpretation, not a measured result, and we publish no volume figures for it.
See the build: ATP SpeditionQuestions, answered
Is agentic AI the same as a chatbot?
No. A chatbot answers in one channel. Anthropic uses "agentic systems" for both fixed workflows and agents that direct their own steps. Our post on agents, chatbots and AI employees sets out the difference.
Does a business with five employees need agentic AI?
Not by default. Anthropic's guide recommends the simplest solution possible and more complexity only when needed. Repeated questions and bookings can often run on fixed steps.
Does PROOF48 sell agentic AI?
Our service pages do not use the word. We sell defined functions with a handoff to a person: website chat, DM and email replies, booking and a CRM.
What does it cost?
AUTOMATE costs 2,997 EUR a month, or 29,970 EUR a year if billed annually. A standalone WhatsApp or voice assistant is a custom build, priced on request.
Where PROOF48 fits
"Agentic" is an umbrella word that covers fixed workflows and agents that choose their own steps, so judge any offer by which steps are fixed, what the system may do and who reads the results. PROOF48's AUTOMATE plan, at 2,997 EUR a month, lists defined functions with a handoff to a person, and we say when a simpler setup would serve you better.
Cosmin Tiu · Founder, PROOF48
Cosmin has worked in online marketing and software development since 2018, and has built with AI every day since January 2023. He still writes code from scratch daily, in Python, React, Rust and C#. PROOF48 ships business websites in 48 hours and invoices afterwards, so every opinion on this blog was paid for in real builds, not in theory.